STATE AND BUSINESS: THEORY AND PRACTICE OF MANAGEMENT
Purpose of the study. To develop a conceptual framework linking social partnership maturity, sustainability reporting quality and institutional conditions supporting regional legitimacy in Kazakhstan’s oil companies.
Methodology. The study synthesises stakeholder, legitimacy and social partnership literature alongside reporting standards and Kazakhstan’s institutional context. It proposes three indices on a common 0–1 scale, explicit coding rules and lagged regression specifications for future testing. No company sample is analysed, indices calculated, regressions estimated or stakeholder surveys conducted.
Originality / value. The framework distinguishes the Social Partnership Maturity Index, based on independently corroborated labour institutions; the Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Disclosure Quality Index, based on public reporting; and the Regional Legitimacy Index, an institutional proxy based on verified regional practices. The latter does not measure stakeholder perceptions, trust or acceptance directly.
Findings. The study develops testable hypotheses and a provisional company typology. Social partnership is expected to be more directly associated with social and governance disclosure than with environmental disclosure. A possible indirect association with regional institutional conditions through reporting quality is proposed. Equal weights, coding rules and classification thresholds require validation. The framework supports future research and reporting improvements but establishes neither empirical relationships nor causal effects.
The purpose of the study is to comprehensively assess the state of the clothing industry based on the analysis of key production, investment and market indicators, as well as to identify the main limitations and prospects for its development. The methodological basis of the research consists of economic and statistical analysis methods, comparative and structural analysis, as well as methods of quantitative data generalization and interpretation. The work uses official statistics, including data on investments, production volumes, retail trade, as well as natural indicators of output.
The uniqueness of the study lies in conducting a comprehensive analysis of the clothing industry in Kazakhstan, while taking into account cost and in-kind indicators, which revealed structural imbalances between investment activity, production and consumption. In contrast to existing research, the focus is on comparing the dynamics of different segments of the industry and identifying the causes of their uneven development.
The results show that, despite significant investment growth and expansion of the retail market, the clothing industry is characterized by a low share in the industrial structure, high dependence on imports and unstable production dynamics. The gap between the growing demand and limited domestic production capabilities has been identified. Based on the analysis, the key directions of the industry's development are substantiated, including the formation of a full production cycle, technological modernization, development of cooperation, increasing product competitiveness and expanding export potential.
Purpose – this article develops an empirical framework for examining how oil price movements and domestic energy consumption influence macroeconomic vulnerability in Kazakhstan. The study contributes to the energy-growth literature by assessing the short-run dynamics and long-run relationship between energyrelated factors and economic performance in a resource-dependent economy.
Methodology – the empirical analysis employs the Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL) approach using annual data for Kazakhstan over the period 2000-2024. Augmented Dickey-Fuller unit root tests are conducted to determine the order of integration, followed by ARDL estimation. Bounds cointegration testing, and diagnostic and stability tests to evaluate model adequacy and robustness.
Originality/value – the study extends the energy-growth nexus literature by examining Kazakhstan as a non-OPEC, resource-dependent transition economy, linking oil price dynamics and domestic energy consumption with macroeconomic vulnerability. Unlike conventional bivariate energy-growth studies, the analysis considers the dynamic interaction of energy-related variables within a broader macroeconomic context.
Findings – the empirical results reveal significant short-run dynamic relationships between oil prices, energy consumption, and economic growth. Economic growth exhibits strong persistence, while oil price shocks affect output with a delayed response, Domestic energy consumption has a statistically significant contemporaneous impact accompanied by lagged adjustment effects. However, the Bounds Test does not confirm the existence of a long-run cointegrating relationship, indicating that Kazakhstan’s macroeconomic vulnerability is driven primarily by short-run adjustments to external energy shocks rather than by a stable long-run equilibrium.
NATIONAL ECONOMY: DEVELOPMENT VECTORS
Research Objective: The aim of the study is to empirically assess the impact of macroeconomic, institutional, and structural factors on Kazakhstan’s export potential. Under global geopolitical shifts, priority is given to identifying the key drivers that determine the opportunities for domestic products to enter the world market.
Methodology: The study employed World Bank statistical data for Kazakhstan covering the period 19952023. To evaluate the relationships among factors, both pairwise and multifactor regression models were constructed based on the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) method. The reliability of the model was confirmed through tests for multicollinearity (VIF), autocorrelation (Durbin-Watson), and residual stationarity.
Originality / Value of the Study: The value of the article lies in its comprehensive approach to analyzing export processes, which considers not only traditional macroeconomic indicators but also institutional variables such as the number of tariff agreements and market entry indices. This approach enables a qualitative assessment of the effectiveness of foreign trade policy.
Research Findings: The modeling results demonstrated a decisive positive effect of GDP (β=0.943) and imports (β=1.213) on export growth. Among institutional factors, the increase in the number of tariff agreements (β=0.113, p=0.001) was proven to significantly stimulate export revenues. However, the hypotheses related to the HH index and EMP index were not confirmed, indicating a high level of export concentration and insufficient strategies for entering new markets. The conclusions can serve as a useful foundation for diversifying Kazakhstan’s export strategy.
The aim of this study is to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current elder care system in Kazakhstan for older persons requiring assistance from others, including the identification of institutional constraints, the analysis of the distribution of care responsibilities among the state, the family, and the market, and the identification of factors contributing to the predominance of unpaid family care, as well as the development of recommendations for improving the elder care system.
The methodology is based on a mixed-methods approach combining qualitative and quantitative methods, including the analysis of legal and regulatory documents, strategic policy documents, statistical data, and scientific literature, as well as a questionnaire survey of 200 households providing care for older people requiring assistance with daily living.
The study’s contribution is a comprehensive analysis of Kazakhstan’s elder care system and the identification of institutional constraints that reinforce a family-oriented care model, under which the primary responsibility for care falls on women, thereby limiting their economic opportunities.
The study’s findings indicate that the low quality and limited availability of institutional care and paid home-based care for most older persons requiring assistance from others, together with prevailing sociocultural norms and gender roles, contribute to the predominance of unpaid family care, which is provided primarily by women, increase the care burden on households, and lead to long-term adverse consequences for employment, pension entitlements, and social protection. The limited scope and fragmented nature of existing government support measures reinforce the family-oriented model of elder care. The findings suggest that expanding government support measures for family care and achieving a more balanced distribution of care responsibilities among the state, the family, and the market could help reduce barriers to the participation of caregivers in paid employment. The findings may be used to inform public policies on elder care, employment, social protection, labour formalization, and the expansion of women's economic opportunities.
The purpose of the study is to identify and systematize the factors of rural development in the Republic of Kazakhstan based on factor analysis, as well as to identify regional differences and imbalances.
Research methods. The work uses economic and statistical methods, including factor and comparative analysis, correlation estimates and methods of grouping regions. The empirical base consists of official statistical data on socio-economic indicators of rural regions of Kazakhstan for 2018-2025.
The originality / value of the study lies in the possibility of using the findings in shaping regional policies and programs for sustainable rural development, as the study emphasizes the need for a differentiated approach to rural management, taking into account their structural features and resource potential.
The results of the study allowed us to identify key groups of factors (economic, infrastructural, demographic and institutional) that shape the trajectories of rural development. Significant regional differences have been identified, reflecting the unevenness of investment activity, production potential and the level of social security.
Purpose of the research – Youth employment is critical to ensuring long-term social and economic stability, especially in developing countries facing demographic and structural transitions. In the Republic of Kazakhstan, amendments to the Law on “State Youth Policy”, enacted in 2023 significantly impacted the statistical indicators of the youth labor market. This study focuses on analysis of structural shifts in the youth labor market in Kazakhstan between 2019 and 2025.
Methodology – To evaluate the dynamics of the labor market both before and after the change in the law, descriptive statistics, time-series studies, calculations of relative fluctuations, and interregional comparisons were used.
Originality / value – The value of this study is that it presents the most comprehensive review of the state of Kazakhstan’s youth labor market after the 2023 reform of state youth policy.
Findings – The findings of the analysis indicate that the largest changes recorded after 2023 were mainly due to a revision of the statistical definition of “youth”, and not to a sharp worsening of the market situation. Despite a considerable increase in the youth labor force due to the change in age limits, the level of unemployment continued to decline, while the level of employment stayed mostly stable. At the same time, significant regional imbalances remained, especially in the levels of self-employment and the prevalent NEET groups, reflecting the continuing structural barriers to the effective inclusion of young people in the job market.
BUSINESS AND GOVERNANCE: ISSUES AND SOLUTIONS
The article is devoted to the study of barriers to the digitalization of supply chains and mechanisms for overcoming them in small and medium-sized businesses.
Purpose. The aim of the work is to identify, systematize and compare the barriers preventing the introduction of digital technologies in small and medium-sized enterprises and large companies based on bibliometric and systematic analysis of scientific literature.
Methodology. The study is based on the application of a bibliometric and systematic review of scientific literature aimed at identifying and analyzing barriers to the digitalization of supply chains, as well as strategies for overcoming them in small and medium-sized enterprises and large companies. The selection of publications was carried out in the Scopus database according to predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria. The final sample included 76 peer-reviewed scientific papers, the results of which were subjected to comparative analysis.
Originality / value. The originality of the research lies in the development of an integrative model of digital transformation of supply chains based on the generalization of the results of the analysis of scientific sources. The proposed model takes into account the impact of enterprise size on digitalization processes and fills the existing gap in the literature associated with insufficient knowledge of the differences between small and medium-sized enterprises and large companies. The practical value of the research is to identify the features of digital technology implementation strategies and mechanisms for overcoming barriers to digitalization in organizations of various scales.
Findings. Found that small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises face more pronounced barriers to the digitalization of supply chains compared to large corporations. Six categories of barriers have been identified: financial, technological, organizational, strategic, regulatory, and human capital-related, the intensity of which varies significantly depending on the scale of the enterprise. It is shown that the geographical location and the level of development of the institutional environment are significant contextual factors determining the results of transformation.
Purpose of the research. This study examines how ethical aspects of marketing communications used by fast food chains in Almaty relate to consumer trust as expressed in online reviews. It focuses on advertising accuracy, price transparency, and service culture.
Methodology. Sentiment analysis and content analysis were applied to 180 reviews of Salam Bro, Doner na Abaya, and I’M published on Google Maps and 2GIS in 2024–2025. Three branches were selected per chain, with ten reviews from each platform per branch. Reviews were examined for emotional tone and the content of ethical and service complaints. Platform ratings were also compared.
Originality (value). The study examines marketing ethics in Almaty’s fast food market through consumer accounts, considering advertising accuracy, payment transparency, and service ethics together. It compares local brands with a chain formed following the rebranding of an international brand.
Findings. Discrepancies between advertised and actual products were associated with negative assessments of trust. Price and payment transparency featured prominently in reviews concerning brand reputation. Staff courtesy may mitigate perceptions of some service inconveniences but does not offset complaints about product safety or advertising accuracy. Platform ratings differed by up to 1.2 points; this difference alone does not establish review manipulation. The findings describe associations within the sample and do not demonstrate causal effects or represent all consumers.
INVESTMENT, FINANCE AND ACCOUNTING
Purpose of the study – To compare quantitative forecasts of daily KASE index risk and explore whether automatically scored Russian-language news headlines add information beyond news counts. The analysis concerns Kazakhstan only.
Research methodology – Official KASE observations support GARCH, EWMA, LSTM and a quantitative GARCH–LSTM baseline. An exploratory extension compares two otherwise matched hybrids with news counts, with and without sentiment. From 15,536 Kursiv records, 10,669 headlines pass the stated candidatecorpus checks. All forecasts share 495 evaluation dates in 2024–2025. Corpus selection is retrospective and does not establish point-in-time information availability.
Originality (value) of the study – The potential contribution is a context-specific benchmark for KASE: a nonlinear correction to GARCH is evaluated separately from the incremental information in Russian-language headline sentiment beyond news counts. The study documents source records, dated forecasts and corpusselection limitations. Its contribution is empirical and exploratory.
Research findings – The quantitative hybrid lowers variance RMSE by 0.087% relative to GARCH (Holmadjusted p = 0.075). Adding headline sentiment to the matched news-count control raises variance RMSE by 0.400% (raw two-sided p = 0.716; adjusted p = 1.000). The sentiment model produces eight 99% VaR exceptions in 495 dates (Kupiec p = 0.206). The experiment does not establish a sentiment benefit under the primary variance loss, a 1–3-day warning effect or capital savings.
The purpose of this study is to identify the main directions and development trends of scientific research devoted to the impact of ESG factors on corporate financial sustainability.
The research methodology is based on a bibliometric analysis of publications indexed in the Scopus database during the period 2016–2026. Data processing was carried out using VOSviewer software and the Bibliometrix package in the R environment. The study employs methods of publication activity analysis, co-citation analysis, bibliographic coupling, international scientific collaboration analysis, and keyword cooccurrence analysis.
The originality of the study lies in its comprehensive examination of the scientific landscape related to ESG factors and corporate financial sustainability. Unlike traditional literature reviews, the conducted analysis made it possible to identify key thematic areas, scientific links among authors and countries, and promising directions for future research.
The findings reveal a steady increase in the number of ESG-related publications after 2019. The results indicate that researchers primarily focus on sustainable development, corporate governance, ESG disclosure, risk management, and corporate financial sustainability. The thematic analysis also demonstrates that financial planning remains a relatively new area of research with considerable potential for further development. The findings may be useful for the design of future studies in the fields of ESG and corporate finance.
This article comprehensively examines the impact of public expenditure on human capital on regional income inequality and poverty across the regions of the Republic of Kazakhstan, based on panel data covering 16 regions over 2010–2025.
Purpose of the research to evaluate the effect of expenditures on education, health and culture on inequality and poverty, and to empirically test the “hidden capital” mechanism that moderates this effect.
Methodology the study combines a two-way fixed effects panel regression with region-clustered standard errors, a composite human capital index constructed via principal component analysis ( PCA ), and an interaction term between human capital and migration.
The importance and value the contribution lies in the formulation, in the Kazakhstani context, of the “hidden capital” concept based on a synthesis of the works of Murphy, Shleifer & Vishny (1991), Beine, Docquier & Rapoport (2008) and LeSage & Pace (2009), and in proposing a formal procedure for its empirical testing.
Findings the analysis provides empirical evidence consistent with three hypotheses: the human capital index significantly reduces the Gini coefficient ( β = −0.0236; p = 0.003); the share of skilled out-migration among the unemployed increases poverty ( β = +0.0613; p = 0.083); the coefficient on the interaction term between the human capital index and the logarithm of migration in the inequality model is positive ( β₃ = +0.0031; p = 0.011), which provides empirical support for the interaction channel of hidden capital. The findings can be used in regional governance to allocate funding for human capital development, retain skilled workers, and plan interregional support measures while taking migration patterns into account.
Research purpose: To identify the theoretical and applied possibilities of modeling the impact of climate risks on insurance payments using ESG indicators. In the current context, climate change, rising air temperatures, changes in precipitation patterns, droughts, floods, strong winds, and other adverse meteorological phenomena are becoming important risk factors for the insurance market. In this regard, the need to assess the potential consequences of climate threats for insurance organizations in advance and to incorporate them into financial models is increasing.
Methodology: The analysis used 42 region-year observations from 14 regions of Kazakhstan for 20222024. Property-damage insurance payouts and premiums were obtained from official insurance statistics. The absolute deviation of annual precipitation from the historical norm was calculated using Kazhydromet data. An author-constructed regional ESG proxy combined emissions, unemployment and public-service quality ratings. The interaction regression controlled for insurance premiums and year.
Value of the study: The value of the study lies in proposing a comprehensive approach to modeling climate risks using ESG indicators by directly linking them to insurance payments. This approach makes it possible to consider climate factors not only as an environmental issue, but also as a financial, social, and governance risk. Research results: The interaction between the absolute deviation of annual precipitation from the historical norm and the regional ESG proxy was not statistically significant (b = −0.121; p = 0.672; n = 42; R² = 0.227). These data therefore did not support a protective moderating role of the regional ESG proxy. Insurance payouts were not separated by climate-related cause, and the regional proxy does not measure insurers’ ESG performance.
ISSN 2789-4401 (Online)













